AmanaOnline

Tax Exemptions Without Capacity Become Punishment

There is a growing conversation around new taxation scheme and and exemptions. In a national like Nigeria, where government revenue needs are high and trust in public institutions is low, it portends great pain and suffering for the tax payer. This government is well known for building such painful systems without regards to the process!

But before we get lost in technical jargon, one fundamental question must be asked honestly: Why tax people in the first place if the majority will eventually be exempt? In principle, tax exemptions do not mean “you do not pay.” They mean “you pay first — then later we will refund you based on rules.” That is how tax is structured in well-managed systems globally. You pay up front, you then file a tax return, you then claim your exemptions and deductions, and if your exemption qualifies, some or all of your money is returned to you.

However, this system only works in countries with strong administrative capacity and clean institutional integrity. It depends heavily on one single factor: refund honesty. If government cannot reliably process returns — if it cannot track payments, verify data, and return money correctly — then the entire concept of exemptions becomes a trap. In such a context, exemptions are no longer relief — they become soft extortion, because you may never actually get back what you qualify for.

For a tax regime based on advanced compliance and post-filing refunds to work, three things must exist simultaneously: (1) a public record system that is clean and accurate; (2) a tax service that is responsive, digital, reliable, and not corrupt; and (3) a credible state promise that “if we owe you a refund — you will get it.” Do we have all three today? Most citizens will quietly say no.

Even the most patriotic person will admit that refunds are already a nightmare in areas like pension processing, scholarship reimbursement, NHIS approvals, procurement refunds, and even simple official payments. How many Nigerians trust that government will return money to them once it has entered government’s hand?

So what then is the logic of designing a tax system that assumes high trust and high automation, when the lived reality is low trust and weak execution? This is the painful contradiction: a good policy implemented in a weak system becomes a bad experience.

Therefore, before introducing mass exemptions that depend on refunds, the real reform should not start with tax rates — it should start with strengthening state capacity. Build digital records. Build refund discipline. Build trust. Only then will tax exemptions function as incentives and relief — instead of becoming punishment for compliance.

Until that day arrives, exemption-based taxation is simply not advisable. It is philosophy from a stronger world — imposed on a weaker administrative reality.